"The Perfect To-Do System"

Author: Mike Brown | Created: 2021-04-7 4:32 | Last Activity: 2021-04-12 9:33

Original Post

2021-04-7 4:32
Ran across the following posts tonight via the Six Colors site (for Mac enthusiasts). The Six Colors writer, Jason Snell, was prompted by the post on the inessential: site. These are both short posts with opinions on the to-do apps that seem to increase in number every year. As you might imagine, they are not fans.

I agree with Snell's last thought: "Hopefully you get more out of whatever system you use than what you put into it. That’s the most important measure."

I've tried Todoist and Things and a few other systems, and honestly -- while Evernote is great for some to-doing -- I always come back to pen and paper and the system is one of Mark's, with simple rules and outsized results for the investment I put in.

Posts:

The perfect to-do system is a mirage – Six Colors
http://sixcolors.com/link/2021/04/the-perfect-to-do-system-is-a-mirage/

inessential: The Perfect To-Do System Is Not Just Around the Corner
http://inessential.com/2021/04/06/the_perfect_to_do_system_is_not_just_around_the_corner

Reply by Aaron Hsu

2021-04-7 7:14
I am also coming to find that the simplest productivity systems that get out of your way tend to be the best.

Reply by Mark Forster

2021-04-7 10:45
Mike Brown:

I agree totally with what the two articles say. That's why I advise people to use paper and pen rather than digital.

The only system I use digital for is The Next Hour, which is my standard system when travelling. It's just more convenient not to have to cart around additional paper. I use an ordinary note page in Evernote on my phone. Even though I don't use any tags, annotations or anything else other than tick boxes, it's still slower than paper and pencil - but much, much faster than any to-do apps.

Reply by Mark Forster

2021-04-7 10:55
However, in response to the implied question "Is there such a thing as the perfect to-do system?", I wrote down a list of what I would want in one:

It must be a long-list system so everything is covered
It must be capable of being run with a single sheet of paper and pen only
The system must be able to access any part of the list at any time
It must keep the whole list under review.
Scanning must be short and easy
There must be no compulsion to do any task at any time
There must be no question(s): it should work on "standing out" only
It must be lightning fast
You shouldn't have to scan the same part of the list more than once before choosing the next task

As far as I can see that set of requirements rules out every single one of my systems (and everyone else's too)!

Reply by avrum

2021-04-7 15:32
The "perfect" system for my temperament and programming has nothing to do with pens, software or workflow rules. It has taken me many years of experimentation and dead ends to appreciate the following: My ability to get things done is related to two things:

1. A relationship
2. Hard landscape appointments/deadlines

1. I have a full private practice with a waitlist. The hard landscape i.e. booked therapy appointments and costs of not showing up (ouch) gets s**t done.

2. My podcast - Pop Parenting - is almost a year old. We're currently ranked #21 on the most listened to Jewish podcasts of 2020-2021. The key variable: my relationship with my co-producer. We have fun... and fun translates into hours of research and commitment to producing one show per week. No lists. No rules. No special paper or software.

3. My books were a combination of hard landscape (contract with publisher) and relationship (co-author with wife (book #2) and my late therapist (book #3)

etc
etc

All this to say, I agree with Snell. It's a good place to be in.

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2021-04-7 15:56
Mark's criteria seem overly prescriptive to my mind. I hereby amend, item for item, as I see it:

It must capture everything that needs doing
It must be capable of being run simply
The system must always give you quick access to any task.
It must keep the whole workload under review.
Scanning must be short and easy
There must be no compulsion to do any task at any time
The process should not inhibit the flow of thought by difficult rules or selection criteria.
** It must direct your action efficiently to tasks that matter now.


I made these amendments because I didn't find your list agreed with my ideal, and I didn't see any reason why your ideal should be excluded from possibly being an ideal system.

I think there are existing systems that may fit these criteria, though it's particular to the individual whether a given system succeeds. In particular, the ** criterion will have the same system succeed or fail for different people who have different patterns of working. (The system I'm operating now seems close to meeting these for me, and especially **, but it doesn't aim for Mark's feature list.)

Avrum: That's a very interesting approach. Instead of a mechanical system, an interpersonal system for ensuring things get done.

Reply by Belacqua

2021-04-7 16:28
Mark,

Simple Scanning certainly seems to come very close to fulfilling your criteria of a perfect system above. To me, those criteria almost read like a description of Simple Scanning! Indeed, up until now, I've considered it the best task management system. Though I continue to try new things.

While those are compelling criteria, Alan has a point about them being somewhat prescriptive. (Alan's amendments are interesting.) Perhaps it would be good if ALL systems had a chance in the running for "perfect system"--including "no list" systems, etc.? Saying that "it must be a long-list system" seems to narrow the range of possibilities.

Reply by Seraphim

2021-04-8 18:09
Very interesting discussion. It has triggered many thoughts on what I want from my time management. It boils down to this:

(A) I always have a clear idea of what I need to be doing and am able to do it easily. If I need to make a decision what to do, the decision is clear, fast, and easy.

(B) I am more and more satisfied with the results I am getting.

(C) When I encounter obstacles or deficiencies with either A or B, I identify the situation quickly and have a straightforward, reliable process to create a new A and B.


Maybe A represents Flow, B represents Throughput or generation of value, and C represents Improvement.

Now that I think about it, I suppose this is what I want from *any* system -- it works without any fuss, it generates the value for which it is intended, and when something goes wrong, that fact becomes clear right away, and there is a clear direction for resolving the situation.

Reply by Mark Forster

2021-04-9 9:54
Belacqua:

<< Perhaps it would be good if ALL systems had a chance in the running for "perfect system" >>

I emphasize that it is a list of what *I* would like to see in a perfect system, and my conclusion is that there is no existing system which meet all my criteria, and probably never could be.

As you say Simple Scanning meets many of the criteria, but I don't find it lightning fast, and my ideal system has to have that quality.

So the real problem is that my definition is actually self-contradictory.

Reply by Mark Forster

2021-04-9 10:07
Seraphim:

<< it works without any fuss, it generates the value for which it is intended, and when something goes wrong, that fact becomes clear right away, and there is a clear direction for resolving the situation. >>

Yes, those are all good points in what we are looking for in the "perfect" system. But they don't get any closer to describing what the ideal system actually looks like, though no doubt you have something in mind!

Reply by Mark Forster

2021-04-9 10:21
Alan Baljeu:

<< Does any system force you to scan the same list multiple times without doing a thing? >>

I was referring to the multiple scans back to the end of the list that take place when doing tasks near the beginning of the list in some versions of FVP.

Reply by Mark Forster

2021-04-9 14:25
Well, I've proved myself wrong by coming up with a system which covers every one of the "perfect system" requirements which I put in my comment, plus Alan Baljeu's revised version, plus I hope Seraphim's as well.

So all that remains is to test it out, and then I will reveal it to the world. Unless of course I decide to keep it to myself so that I have no competition when I become world dictator... mwahahaha.

Reply by Belacqua

2021-04-9 16:12
Mark,

<>

Interesting. For me, Simple Scanning is lightning fast. But then, I tend to keep my list pretty short.

On the perennial topic of the best system, I recently read Mark's 2016 blog series on "what type of system... would win the evolutionary stakes." http://markforster.squarespace.com/blog/2016/1/25/types-of-lists-i-the-catch-all-list.html

Fascinating reading (even if it's a few years old). I was struck by the fact that even "using no list at all" came in for consideration as a contender. It takes humility and open-mindedness to entertain that possibility when you've spent years creating list-based systems! The positive verdict on "no-list" systems in the 2016 series was one thing that convinced me to give them a (belated) try. Though I haven't gotten around to doing an extended trial yet.

Reply by Belacqua

2021-04-9 17:14
P.S.

On the criteria of an ideal system: I suppose one possible addition would be "fun to use." (Granted, that's going to be subjective.)

Indeed, even a less-than-perfect system can probably produce good results if one enjoys using it and sticks to it. Previously, Mark has written persuasively on the virtues of sticking to one system. Which can be tough to do given the abundance of exciting ideas on this website!

As an example of what I mean: AF1 was a great system but perhaps it wasn't perfect. Yet I have fond memories of using it some years ago. And I used it for a good stretch of time. How much one enjoys a system is important in my experience.

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2021-04-9 18:29
I don't know "fun" is the right term. I do believe an ideal system must not be a chore to use. If the process makes you feel like quitting, or not picking it up again the next time, that's not a good process. So maybe an ideal process entices you to use it and feels rewarding when you do. AF4 was a good example of that at times. The feeling of progress on that Old list was motivating.

Reply by Mark Forster

2021-04-9 20:53
Alan Baljeu:

<< AF4 was a good example of that at times. The feeling of progress on that Old list was motivating. >>

I think what you mean is "AF4 is a good example of that at times. The feeling of progress on that Old list is motivating".

Reply by Seraphim

2021-04-9 22:14
<< Well, I've proved myself wrong by coming up with a system which covers every one of the "perfect system" requirements which I put in my comment, plus Alan Baljeu's revised version, plus I hope Seraphim's as well. >>

Looking forward to hearing more about it! Or to the coming New World Order, if you decide to take that route. :-)

Reply by Seraphim

2021-04-9 22:22
Belacqua - << How much one enjoys a system is important in my experience >>

I agree with that -- the system should have intrinsic motivation -- a good kind of inertia, that pulls you to keep going with it. If you must keep forcing yourself to use it, then eventually you will stop.

Reply by Mark Forster

2021-04-9 23:57
Belacqua:

<< It takes humility and open-mindedness >>

I may be open-minded but no one's ever accused me of being humble before!

Reply by Mark Forster

2021-04-10 0:04
Seraphim:

<< Looking forward to hearing more about it! Or to the coming New World Order, if you decide to take that route. >>

I think you're going to get the coming New World Order regardless.

But my new system is coming along nicely. It's very simple and is a case of re-arranging some of the "bricks" already established in older systems.

Reply by Belacqua

2021-04-10 0:05
Alan,

What you say makes sense to me. An ideal system should draw you in.

Alan Baljeu:

<< AF4 was a good example of that at times. The feeling of progress on that Old list was motivating. >>

Mark Forster:
<>

I too was guilty of using past tense to describe the older systems. For sure, AF1 and AF4 are still great systems!

Reply by Belacqua

2021-04-10 0:22
Mark Forster:

<>

Happy to be the first, I guess.

Reply by Seraphim

2021-04-10 3:10
Oh! I meant *your* New World Order!

Reply by Christopher

2021-04-10 20:43
FV comes closest to Mark‘s list of requirements.

Reply by Mark Forster

2021-04-11 10:21
Christopher:

<< FV comes closest to Mark‘s list of requirements. >>

Apart from the fact that once you have chosen your tasks you have to do them in order and you are confined to those tasks - which breaks two of my requirements.

Reply by Seraphim

2021-04-12 0:43
I just thought of another set of criteria for the perfect system -- my children must be able to use it:
-- Easy for me to teach to them
-- Easy for them to adopt and use
-- Easy for them to sustain and get value from it

Reply by Mark Forster

2021-04-12 9:33
Seraphim:

<< my children must be able to use it >>

Good point.

Only in my case it's grandchildren. My children all seem quite capable of running their lives successfully without my help!